Magical Thinking

"I can't believe you would not help. Not if it means losing who we are in the process, because then we're no better than she is. I know that you are still processing the fact that you can use magic, and I know that I have been pushing you out of your comfort zone. But that's only because I believe in you, and... I'm... I'm terrified. She makes me feel powerless. Nxyly's magic is unlike anything I've ever faced. I feel like I don't know how to beat her, and if she gets all seven totems, I won't be able to. You can do something I can't. I need your help, Lena."

- Kara Danvers and Lena Luthor

Synopsis
Lena is uncertain about using her magical abilities to help Supergirl retrieve the second totem from Nyxly. William struggles to write a story on the Super Friends that makes both the heroes and Andrea happy. Meanwhile, Kelly is thrilled Esme has found a new home, but things go awry and the little girl's future is put in danger.

Protagonists

 * Super Friends
 * Sentinel (Alex Danvers)
 * Guardian (Kelly Olsen)
 * Martian Manhunter/John Jones (J'onn J'onzz)
 * Dreamer (Nia Nal)
 * Lena Luthor
 * Supergirl (Kara Zor-El)
 * CatCo Worldwide Media
 * William Dey
 * Andrea Rojas
 * Esme

Antagonists

 * Nyxlygsptlnz
 * Mitch
 * Naxim Tork
 * Reign

Other Characters

 * Brainy
 * Elizabeth Walsh
 * Joey Davis
 * Dana Ford
 * Joe Ford
 * Frank Creed
 * Igor Starros
 * Lucha Libre
 * Lois Lane
 * Bishop Myers, 23
 * Betty Ray, 42
 * Doug Scott
 * Jay Hendrix
 * Zane Tomley
 * Benji Swift
 * Romeo Sheen
 * Cadell Chin
 * Buddha
 * William Dey's Father
 * God
 * Mxy
 * Sherman Marks, 28
 * David
 * Goliath

Teams and Organizations

 * Super Friends
 * Legion of Super-Heroes
 * CatCo Worldwide Media
 * California Department of Social Services
 * John Jones, Private Investigator
 * DEO
 * Burnett Arena
 * KGMQ News 3
 * NCPD
 * United Nations
 * United Nations Security
 * National City Botanical Gardens
 * 5
 * NCT (National City Transit)
 * National City Tribune
 * City Hall
 * Ormfell Building
 * 7 News
 * Daily Planet
 * National City Museum of Science and Technology

Species

 * Humans
 * Green Martians
 * Human-Naltorian Hybrids
 * Kryptonians
 * Imps
 * Infernians
 * Dyralians
 * Phantoms

Objects and Concepts

 * Legion Cruisers
 * Cosmic Menagerie
 * Magic
 * Book of Spells
 * Invenire Res Amissa
 * Auge Navitas Pro Omnibus Homnibus
 * Jyrryd's Crystal
 * Power-Dampening Cuffs
 * Anti-Magic Cuff
 * Image Inducers
 * Hand of the Soldier
 * Sentinel Suit
 * Energy Guns
 * Dreamer Suit
 * Supergirl Suit
 * AllStone Totems
 * Courage Totem
 * Humanity Totem
 * Hope Totem
 * Dream Totem
 * Truth Totem
 * Destiny Totem
 * Love Totem
 * Guardian Suit
 * Martian Manhunter Suit

Locations

 * Earth-Prime
 * Earth
 * North America
 * United States of America
 * California
 * National City
 * Hammersmith Tower
 * Kara Danvers' Loft
 * John Jones, Private Investigator
 * Tower
 * Hochschild Residence
 * Burnett Arena
 * CatCo Plaza
 * Ford Residence
 * National City Botanical Gardens
 * City Hall
 * Ormfell Building
 * Maine and 5th
 * 8th Street
 * Newfoundland
 * Limestone Barrens
 * Europe
 * Netherlands
 * The Hague
 * Kaznia/Kasnia
 * Corto Maltese
 * Corvon-4
 * Phantom Zone
 * Fifth Dimension